Saturday, June 11, 2011

Greg Whisenant on How He Turned a Burglary Into a Business Opportunity and What it Takes to be a Successful Entrepreneur

Greg Whisenant is founder and CEO of Public Engines, which makes the CrimeReports.com web application. Previously, he was a senior legislative advisor for law firm Hale and Dorr (now Wilmer Hale), where he lobbied the US Congress and Clinton Administration. Greg also worked for several years as a legislative aide to U.S. Senator Robert F. Bennett (R-UT), where he handled law enforcement, technology and telecommunications issues. Greg also served as a consultant in the launch of Unitus, which uses private capital to supercharge successful microfinance institutions throughout the world. He helped create a microfinance bank for a small village in Mali, West Africa.

Recently, Ken Frei sat down to interview Greg.

Have you been an entrepreneur your whole life? What are some of the things you have done that have led you to where you are now?

I have a wide and varied background, and it doesn't have a clear theme to it necessarily. I started out in politics where I worked for
U.S. Senator Bennett in Washington for several years as a legislative aide. Then, I went and got a master's degree and went back and worked as a lobbyist. 

I had a political beginning, but I was always naturally drawn to business. My energy was there. I think it's way too early to declare myself a success, but if I were to point to anything in my past that has led to success, being able to tie together different experiences from across a broad spectrum has been really helpful.

I moved from Washington to Salt Lake in 2000 and joined a dotcom startup that imploded. Then, I started my own little company doing some consulting and some computer work. That first business was really tough. I learned a ton and it was a great way to get my bearings in terms of trying to understand how I would attack the market. I launched Public Engines and Crimereports.com with a partner about four years ago.

I read that you majored in English in college.

I did.

That is an interesting background for someone who has started his own business. How has that degree translated to running a business?

It hasn't been perfect, I can tell you that. I certainly feel like I'm at a disadvantage compared to some of my peers and others who are trying to start businesses. I think that having a broad knowledge base and having discipline in other industries has been helpful.

I think I would be in worse shape if I had focused exclusively on business. It has really helped to have a broad understanding of different types of industries and different perspectives that help me know how to run the business.

What are some things that you do to make up for the business training that you didn't get in school? How have you acquired that training yourself?

From the School of Hard Knocks, and there have been plenty, believe me. It's a truly humbling experience to try to create a business and get it going. There have been a lot of fits and starts, and many, many mistakes along the way. It has been an inelegant liftoff.

I've tried to surround myself with people who are knowledgeable, subject matter experts. I'm also naturally a learner and I don't assume that I have all the answers. Maybe that works to my disadvantage sometimes. It helps for me to think, “I really need to beef up on this or on that.” I try to constantly improve my skill-set. That's definitely been part of the process.

Tell me how Crimereports.com got started.

I was living in Arlington, Virginia, and I let a burglar into my building on accident. I didn't know he was a burglar, I just figured he was another tenant. From that experience, I got to meet my local police department and I went to a community meeting. Through that dialogue, I came to understand that there was a disconnect between members of the public and law enforcement agencies.

There are 18,000 agencies in the United States, which is a lot. They don't have a lot of resources, and they are really doing things in old ways. I saw that there was an opportunity to use not just web 2.0 tools, but other Internet tools that were out there to create a better, more comprehensive engagement between the public and law enforcement.

Then, it was when Google Maps launched that I started to get really serious about it. That was when the light bulb went off. I was not the pioneer in this regard; there were other people who had created mash-ups of crime data on maps and I saw an opportunity. We had plenty of momentum already and saw an opportunity to serve law enforcement with high quality, easy-to-use products delivered from the cloud that helps prevent, reduce, and solve crime.

Why have you chosen to locate your company here in Utah as opposed to an area like Silicon Valley or like Boston? What about the Utah business environment has been good for you?

I think Utah has the right balance of opportunity and talented people. That's a pretty important thing. There is also a great lifestyle here. There are solid values and people who want to work hard. There is just a culture of wanting to get something done and really make an impact. It is, in many ways, all about the money at some point in time and people definitely care about that, but I think they feel a higher sense of purpose than a lot of people that I've met with. It's just a great culture.

It's a great place to be professionally. There is plenty of opportunity. There are a lot of resources for entrepreneurs. There are a lot of really smart people who think at a high level. I just think it's a great place to live and have a business. There is a basic cost structure here that is a little more tolerable for a start-up. It feels like it's a little more manageable. Utah has the right balance and the right key elements that you need to infuse your business with talent.

What do you do personally to be innovative in your company? What are some strategies you use to innovate?

I look for patterns in other industries. I try to look at what other companies and people are doing out there on the Internet and in the broader business ecosystem. I look at that through the filter of law enforcement and say, "When I see what other people are tying together—can I tease together a pattern that makes sense?" 99% of the ideas go by the wayside, but occasionally I get a glimpse of something good.

Something that we've done well at Crime Reports is that we have focused on consumers. That has forced us to have simplicity in our user interface, making it easier for our law enforcement. I'm so pleased with the UI that we've come up with across our product suite. I think our products are naturally intuitive and people understand how to use it just by looking at it. They don't need comprehensive training and it's not tedious. Our users are surprised by the simplicity and that’s a very powerful thing for a government agency. I mean, nobody wants to be tortured in their daily work.

I also read a lot. I really do try to read interesting books that are compelling. I read stuff from people that I respect and people that I don't. I try to fill myself with information in order to get a lot of ideas.

What drives you to be successful?

I can't muster the will to do work that I don't truly enjoy. That is a blessing and a curse. I really have to feel like the work I do has an impact. I want to be able to say, “This does something. It really accomplishes something.” I guess I'm naturally drawn in that way, where I'd rather have some impact or none at all. If I don't genuinely enjoy it, I'm just not going to be good at it. I just won't have my heart and soul in it. That's really the driver.

I also want to continually improve. I always assume that I don't have the answers. I really try to understand what our company can be doing better. We genuinely want to understand our customers and find out from them how we can improve. The more successful you get the harder that gets, but fortunately it has been pretty easy for me.

That whole concept of iterating and validating your business model with customers - at one point in time I think it saved our company. It really did. You have to listen to customers because they’re able to give insights into the direction that your company should go. I was willing to hear that and it kept us from heading down a path that I think would have gotten us in trouble.

What did you do to get back on the right track?

I got on a plane and flew out and talked to customers. I interviewed them. I sat down with a tape recorder like you're doing right now. I said, “This is not a sales process, this is a listening exercise. Tell me about how you do your work. Show me what you do. Tell me what's missing with our product.” Then, we genuinely tried to solve their problems. It was a very rewarding experience for me when we were able to make our customers happy.

Are there any particular books that you would recommend?

Right now I'm reading two books, both of which I'd highly recommend. They're both painful and wonderful. One is called
Rework by the 37Signals founders. It is intensely painful to read for an entrepreneur. The other is called Not All Those Who Wander Are Lost by Steve Blank. It's a collection of all his blog posts and acutely painful as well.

I would have loved to have read these books as I was starting my first business. They're so powerful and infused with wisdom. Neither book is very well known, but they’re both great.

Do you have any other advice that you want to give to entrepreneurs?

Just do it. There are a lot of good ideas and it doesn't take that much to actually start doing some work. You don't have to devote your full time and attention to it. You can start in little ways. Just understand that all of your experiences are going to contribute in some way to how you start, launch, and run a business.

People can get lost in this idea that it's just too hard to start.  I'm no more talented than the next guy, as any number of people in this building would attest. It's just a matter of saying, "Hey, I'm going to go out and do this," and then start doing something.

I would also advise entrepreneurs to keep their costs low. It's always nice to test out the model in the smallest, cheapest way possible. It really helps you to think through where you're trying to go.

If I were to give one other piece of advice it would be to work on networking. Get to know people and genuinely try to help them and also have them help you with what you are trying to do. It’s really valuable to know people and have them know who you are and what you‘re working on. It‘s a good practice.

Friday, May 20, 2011

Eric Jacobsen- Why investing will be harder in future years and the makeup of a great entrepreneur

Eric is the managing partner and a co-founder of Dolphin Capital. He formerly served as CEO of Winder Farms. Eric was also the founder and CEO of TNT Sound which was sold in 1983, Vice President of MECA Software which went public and was sold to H&R Block in 1994 and Founder and President of Home Financial Network which was sold to Sybase in 2000. Early in his career, he was an investment banker with Smith Barney.

Recently, Ken Frei sat down to interview Eric.

Have you been an entrepreneur your whole life? How did you get into the business world?

I don't know if I have been an entrepreneur my whole life, but I started my first company when I was in college. It sort of happened by chance more than me setting out to start a company because I had some grand vision or plan. I didn't write a business plan or anything. I just started selling stuff and making money and doing something I loved. One thing led to another and pretty soon I had a business on my hands and I was able to grow that business and be fairly successful.

So my entrance into starting companies was really by fluke rather than any grand plan or strategy. In fact, when I graduated, someone told me that I should add that I was an entrepreneur on my resume, and I spelled it wrong. I didn’t even know what it was. I guess I have been an entrepreneur, but again it was not by design.

I thought I always wanted to be a CEO of a business but I don’t know if I even knew what that really meant. I figured that I needed to learn how to read financial statements and how to raise money and deal with the financial side of things. I also assumed that I needed to learn how to sell, because I think sales are important for every company, and I needed to understand operations. So, when I graduated I actually became an investment banker. My logic was that I would learn a lot about finances and raising money and that it would be a great experience.

And then I joined a small software technology company. I hated investment banking. I wanted to get out of it and I wanted to move to back to San Francisco. I just wanted to get out of New York City because I was from California and software and technology was a hot thing at the time. If you were young, you could rise quickly in the industry because there weren’t a lot of old people in it. As a young person, I figured it was a great way to go to California and a great way to be able to get on a fast career trajectory.

I joined a small computer software company that made personal finance and tax software. There were about 20 people in the company when I joined. I was head of sales and marketing and I was learning how to sell in real time. I thought it would be a great experience. We ended up growing this company and we took it public in 1993. We ultimately sold it to H&R Block who bought it primarily for our tax software expertise. I guess I was an entrepreneur but not really. I joined this small company and I was one of the key players, but I don’t know if you would call that entrepreneurial or not.

Right place at the right time, I guess, right?

You bet. No doubt about that. And then I did start a company. My partner and I started
a company called Home Financial Network and we were at the very beginning of the internet banking revolution. Again, sort of the right place at the right time. We raised 5 million dollars of venture capital money off of a power point business plan that we wrote. We ended up, over the life of the company, raising about $22.5 million. We were square in the middle of the dot com revolution and we were one of the larger internet banking software providers. We sold to customers like Wells Fargo and helped them build their internet banking sites. 30 of the top 100 banks in the United States were customers of ours. We had several international customers as well. We grew that business and we ended up selling that to Sybase, a public database software company out of California. So that really was my long-winded entrance into being an entrepreneur.

It sounds like you did several technology based things, but your education was more on the business side of things. Is that right?

I was a political science major when I was in school, so I knew nothing about business, marketing, or sales. I had none of the classical training required to be in business.

What are some important skills that entrepreneurs need to have to be successful? If they don’t have classical training, like you didn’t, how can they gain those skills?

You know that’s a question I could talk about for a long time. Years ago, I went to a venture capital conference in San Francisco held by one of the top venture capital firms. There was a Stanford Business School professor who was going to give a speech on “What are the ten traits of a successful entrepreneur?” I was very excited to go to see what this was. Then, the business school professor put up his number one trait and I looked at it and said, “Really?!” Well, that’s not me, but I’m sure that I’m going to have the next nine. And he put up the second one and I said, “Really?!” That’s not me either.

It turns out that I had six of the ten traits that he said were important for a successful entrepreneur to have. And it got me thinking about what really makes a great entrepreneur. If you think about it, there are introverted entrepreneurs and extroverted entrepreneurs. There are the technology and science entrepreneurs who are brilliant, and there are political science major entrepreneurs. There are people who are great at sales, and there are people who are not great at sales. There are people who are all about brand and image, and people who don’t even know what that is. Entrepreneurs literally, in my opinion, take all sizes, shapes, and varieties.

And so for years, I sort of thought about, what does it take? And my conclusion was that it ultimately takes two things: One is your willingness to take that first step and to go for it. It’s just having enough confidence and believing that you can pull it off. Most people are afraid and don’t do it. I think you need to have guts to just go for it. So that’s one.

I think the second trait, and I have talked to a lot of entrepreneurs, is that they refuse to fail. Most successful entrepreneurs have faced bankruptcy or debt or destruction. They have faced incredibly dark, gloomy days, where they had no right to continue to be in business. But somehow, the successful entrepreneur figures out how to make it happen.
In my opinion, those are two very important traits for an entrepreneur to have.

Greg Warnock has some interesting opinions and theories about successful entrepreneurs. He believes that successful entrepreneurs tend to share the information and not hoard it. They tend to put themselves in the middle of an idea generation process. If somebody had an idea, they’re willing to provide suggestions on how to make it better so that more people come to them with their ideas. Then, the more ideas they get, the more knowledgeable they get. The more knowledgeable they get, the more they can share with other people. They become the center of this idea universe and therefore, they have lots of ideas and they have connections to a lot of people. They understand what competitive things are out there. They become knowledge centers.

Greg thinks that entrepreneurs tend to have good networks. They tend to meet people, connect with people, and build networks. Whether it is with technology guys, other scientists, computer science geeks, salesmen, or just good business people, entrepreneurs tend to be good network builders.

Greg believes that entrepreneurs are willing to, what he calls “give a gift". In other words, I will, as an entrepreneur, reach out to somebody or take their phone call or help them in any way I can. Successful entrepreneurs tend to be very giving. And by giving, without asking for anything in return, they build this army of people who want to help them be successful and who want to give back to them.

So, it’s not about taking certain classes or reading balance sheets or having any particular skill. Those things are all valuable, but at the end of the day it’s more of a personality type than a skill set.

How did you transition from starting companies into private equity investing and some of the things you are doing now with Dolphin Capital?

I sold my internet banking company in January of 2000 around when the dot com crash
happened. And in my opinion, in those ensuing 3 to 5 years, there was no premium, or what I call founders premium. There was no benefit to taking the risk of starting a company. If I took the risk to start a company and got to the point where I could raise meaningful venture capital, the valuation that VC firms were giving was so bad, that I would end up with only 10 or 15 percent of the company having taken a lot of risk. I could have gotten a job as a hired gun at a technology company and gotten 10 or 15 percent in options without taking all the risk. So there was no real incentive during those couple of years to start a company.

I kept looking and trying to figure out what to do next. I didn't want to be a CEO anymore. It is a lot of work to be a CEO and to run a company. You make enormous personal and family sacrifices to be an entrepreneur and a CEO if you are really going to be successful. I was at a phase of my life where I wasn't sure that I wanted to do that.
I was then approached by a gentleman who suggested that I start a fund and I said, "No, I don't want to be in that business. That’s the dark side. I don't like venture guys." And then he said, “Well, what if I put up the money?" And I said" well that would be different. If I don’t have to go out and fundraise, that would be different." So, I basically raised a fund from five high-net-worth individuals, and just as an entrepreneur would, sort of figured out how to start that business instead of starting another technology company. And I’ve loved it by the way. It’s been awesome.

Now that you’ve got that going, how do you decide what types of things to invest in? What types of ventures really get you excited?

At Dolphin Capital, we like companies that have a proven product. What we mean by proven is that they are generating revenue and some level of income. We’re not smart enough to be able to predict if some new technology is going to be the next Google. We like a product that has already been built and has customers that are voting with their pocketbooks and saying "Yes, we value this product, and we will pay “X” for it." So, that’s sort of criteria one.

Criteria two is that we need to believe that we can grow it. We are growth people. We’re not really venture in the traditional venture world. I would say we are more growth, private equity. We want to find things that have revenue and profits and that we can use our skills to grow. We believe that we are good at sales and marketing, and we believe we are good at management, and picking management and we believe we are good at finance. We don't believe we are good at inventing products or technologies or markets. We’re not smart enough to do that. So, we want to start with something that's proven and figure out how to make it materially better.

We want to be passionate about the industry that we’re working with. We invest in things that we are excited about and that we think would be really fun. Philosophically we believe that if we're building a widget just to make money, it's harder to be financially successful. We believe that we have to really enjoy it and be users of it. It makes it easier to get up and go to work every day. We have to really care.

We also have to like the people we're working with. Philosophically, we believe that life's too short to work with people we don't enjoy just to make a buck. We really want to care about, like, respect, and admire the people that we're investing in.

We also rarely invest in a company that has the perfect business plan. What I mean by that is that if somebody has got everything perfectly figured out, then they probably don't have any need to come to us. It's okay when people come to us and they aren’t very great at sales and marketing. That's probably almost the best thing for us because then we believe that we can add a lot more value than just money. Or, if they have great sales and marketing and a great product, they might not have very good financial controls, or reporting mechanisms. We're good at that stuff. We're a bunch of numbers geeks, and spreadsheet geeks. We're cool with that kind of stuff. We like businesses where we believe we can add value above and beyond the money.

Has your investment strategy changed at all with the slower economic times that we've had recently? And if so, talk about how that's changed.

The strategy has not changed. It's been much harder to get deals done because what we are willing to pay and what entrepreneurs are hoping to get is farther apart now. The gap widens in these tough economic times. So, it has been much harder to get deals done, but our strategy has not changed.

How do you see the private equity and venture capital landscape changing over the next few years?

I'm more familiar with the private equity side than the venture capital side. On the private equity side, I think there's going to be a lot fewer deals that are done purely with financial maneuvering in order to get a return. I think there's going to be higher value placed on private equity firms who can go in and add value above and beyond just injecting money, strapping on a bunch of debt, doing some financial figuring, and flipping out of the company in 2 years. I think private equity is going to get a lot harder, and therefore there is going to be a lot less of it.

What kinds of things do you think investors will have to do that will make it harder for them?

They're going to have to be more involved. They're going to have to roll up their sleeves. They're going to have to bring greater expertise within the companies as opposed to finding debt, adding a bunch of leverage, adding sub debt and more sub debt, and sucking down management fees. Firms are going to have to add real value as opposed to just buying low and putting on a bunch of debt and stripping out a little bit of costs and flipping it in two years for a nice return.

I think that the fundraising is going to be much harder for venture and private-equity firms over the next few years for a whole variety of reasons. And I think that the trend toward bigger and bigger private equity and venture firms is going to subside. There are going to be a lot more small, niche oriented firms as opposed to big, giant monolithic, huge firms that are wielding billions of dollars. I think people are going to be looking for more local expertise and industry expertise within a private equity firm, instead of trying to be all things to all people.

Why have you chosen to locate and invest here in Utah as opposed to Silicon Valley or Boston or another entrepreneurial hub like that? What do you like about being in Utah?

I am a big, big fan of Utah on this topic. When my partner and I started our first personal financial software company that we sold to H&R Block, we had our technology center in Connecticut. It was very difficult to find state of the art technologists in Connecticut. The state had great sales and marketing people, but not really great technologists. We sold that business to H&R Block and we started our new firm.

We wanted to put our technology center somewhere other than Connecticut. We looked at Boston and we looked in the Raleigh-Durham area in the Raleigh-Durham triangle. We looked in Austin and we were looking in Silicon Valley. We really thought we would put our technology center in Silicon Valley for all of the obvious reasons that somebody would go to Silicon Valley.

One of the guys that we worked with before was originally from Utah and he said, “You know, you should look in Utah.” My reaction was, “Utah?! Why would we ever go to Utah?” And he said, “Well, let me just go and explore”. I honestly thought it was just a way for him to get a free trip to go and see his family. But when he came back, it happened to be a moment in time when Novell had just purchased Word Perfect. And Novell was laying off and getting rid of a lot of the Word Perfect people when the two companies were joined together.

We were able to put together an unbelievable technology team in Orem, literally over the weekend. We found 10 programmers that were unbelievably talented and cost us probably 30-50% less than what we thought we were going to have to pay if we were in Silicon Valley. That was a great benefit. It was probably the single best decision we made in starting and building that company, called Home Financial Network.

We had an unbelievable technology team here. The work ethic here is absolutely fantastic. People don't go out and party all night long and therefore come in late the next day. It's a very loyal employee base. The odds that they are going to have somebody from Silicon Valley come along and offer them 20% more if they move to California are pretty slim. Most people aren't willing to pack up and leave their families and leave Utah for just a little bit more money. The ties here are too strong. I think there is much better loyalty here.

From the investment side of things, Utah is still, in my opinion, undercapitalized from a venture and private equity standpoint. If you really think about it, on the private equity side, there was Huntsman Gay, Sorenson, Peterson, and Dolphin, my firm, is probably the fourth largest private equity firm. And we're tiny. And Huntsman Gay has basically left Utah. 

Then, on the venture side, there is vSpring, UV, Mercato, and basically not much else. So, there's just isn't a lot of money chasing the deals here. There's not as much competition for the quality of deals that come out of the state of Utah. For people in Utah trying to raise capital, they constantly have to go to Silicon Valley in order to get money. And I think there's a great hotbed of entrepreneurial ideas and entrepreneurs in this state that are worth investing in.

What advice would you give to entrepreneurs who are seeking investment here in Utah?

My belief is that if you actually have a good idea, a good product, a good company, a good plan, then it is easy to raise money. It's hard to raise money if you don't have a good product, a good idea, a good team, and a good plan. There's money out there that wants to invest. You just have to find the right mix of all the factors that are going to make it successful.

I think that entrepreneurs often fall in love with their own ideas. They don't do enough market research to find out and understand who their competitors are. They don’t know who else is trying to do what they are doing and what all the other forces are that are pressing against whatever their idea is. I think that entrepreneurs are often naïve about what their real competitive advantage is with their products and ideas, versus whatever else is out there. Are their products really that different? Are they really that much better? Are they really earth-shattering? Do they really appeal to a broad group of people? Is there really a big market for whatever their idea is?

Entrepreneurs really need to understand their markets. I think entrepreneurs usually understand their products really well and their customers that they have sold or targeted so far. They understand those very well. But I don't know that they understand the forces beyond that. Who are their competitors? Who's threatening them? What other trends are in their favor or against them? I think having a very real understanding of that would help them raise money because as investors, that's the stuff we're looking at. And that's the kind of stuff we're comparing it to and thinking about when an entrepreneur is sitting there pitching his idea. This guy knows his product pretty well, but who's going to crush him? Who's going to prevent them from being successful? What are the other forces out there?

Are there any good books or blogs that you would recommend to people who want to be more informed on investing or entrepreneurship?

I am not a big reader. I have read some great business books, certainly. I don't know that there are great entrepreneurship books. I personally read general publications a lot, such as Fortune magazine, just to know what's going on, what's happening on the economy, what businesses are doing and trying to do. I read the Economist and I read a lot of industry trade rags. I don't know if there are any books that I would say are great books on setting out a road map for an entrepreneur or how to be successful entrepreneur. I think there's just an unfortunate dearth of good entrepreneurship writing out there because it is hard to quantify. It's hard to put an entrepreneur in a bucket, you know? It’s hard to write something that says, “Here is what an entrepreneur is. Here’s what it takes to be successful.” It's just hard to that. Therefore, there's not much written that's very good in my opinion. 

Friday, May 13, 2011

Jesse Stay- 11 questions for the social media expert

Jesse Stay is CEO and founder of SocialToo.com, a site that complements the social networking experience with useful tools and analytics. A speaker, author, developer, and entrepreneur, Jesse wrote two books, ―I‘m on Facebook, Now What???‖, and FBML Essentials (O‘Reilly), and was recently named one of 20 developers to follow on Twitter, as well as one of 10 entre-preneurs to follow on Twitter by Mashable.com. Jesse writes regularly on his successful blog, StayNAlive.com, and has contributed to the top two Face-book blogs, InsideFacebook and AllFacebook.

Recently, Ken Frei sat down to interview Jesse.

Have you been an entrepreneur your whole life? What led you to get into the social media space?

I’ve always had a bit of entrepreneur blood in me. Growing up, I was always the kid with the lemonade stand on the street. In high school I would get artists at my school to give me their drawings for free and I would create t-shirts out of those and sell the t-shirts for profit. I had another business where I would go to Sam’s Club and buy the bulk candy and then sell it for a lot more money than I bought it for. That was really popular. Once I graduated from high school, I was the idea guy. I was always coming up with new ideas for things that I wanted to go out and start. I never had the guts to go out and quit my job and do it though.

It wasn’t until about four years ago, that I started branching out on my own. I was working at a company called Media General and they owned newspapers and TV stations throughout the Southeast. We were paying very close attention to MySpace and to Twitter, which at that time was just barely starting to come out. Facebook was out in niche audiences in the University scene and there was another network, Pounce, which was out at the time as well as a few others. We were paying attention to those networks because we saw that they could be the future. Newscorp ended up buying MySpace and they were somewhat of a competitor with us. We were very interested with whether or not this could this be the future of publishing online and it turns out that it was. It got my interest because I was working in the division that was paying attention to that. And then Facebook opened up to everyone and I was finally able to get an account. I actually joined to be able to spy on my sisters who were a lot younger at the time. But the programmer and the marketer and the entrepreneur in me started asking questions like, “Well, what could I do with this platform?” Then Facebook released their platform to their website. It was at that point that I realized that I can actually do something with this and I can start making programs and write applications that not only work like a website, but that promote themselves because they get put in the relationships of all my close friends and family that are on Facebook.

I had a few ideas that I had been building and I decided at that point to build an app. I called it the LDS app. It was an app that I used to learn how to do Facebook development and it was targeted towards people of the LDS faith. I ended up selling that app and it was the modest amount that I received from that sale that made me realize that I could now go off and start on my own. So like I said, I’ve always been an entrepreneur at heart, but at that point I started trying all kinds of things.

So now you run SocialToo, a social management website. What has your growth been the last 5 years?

It has been good for the most part. When I started SocialToo, we started on the model of one-time payments for different features. We had our auto-follow feature where we would allow you to catch up on all of your previous followers and we would charge a one-time fee of five bucks for the life of the product. We still have another feature that allows you to get a nightly email of the people that followed you and stopped following you the previous day. We used to charge a one-time $20 fee for that. Once you bought it, it was enabled forever. We had several other features like that. We had a web feature that allowed you to delete all of your friends. That’s one that Twitter made us remove. We had one that allowed you to un-follow the people that had un-followed you. Twitter made us remove that one as well. We’ve had several over the lifetime of the company.

I was doing really well at the start. I was making up to four or five thousand a month, which is pretty good for one person in less than a year. The problem is that the one-time payment structure quickly trickles out. I had no problem hitting the blogs. We were on Tech Crunch, we were on Mashable, and we were on Venture Beat. You name the blog and we were on it. We were getting the attention that we needed, but eventually Twitter started removing features and we weren’t able to charge for everything we wanted to. The un-follow features were our most popular features and they were completely removed by Twitter.

I decided to move to a monthly payment model. Almost everything that we offer now is based off of a $30 per month payment plan. We have all those features, the auto follow, the daily email. We have some filtering mechanisms for direct messages on Twitter and we have some Facebook features coming out here really soon that will allow you to build a Facebook campaign on our site along with some other things. All of those things are included in the $30 a month and we continually allow you to add as many accounts as you want. We have stats that go along with that so you can track to progress of your followers over time. We’re not quite to where we used to be in terms of growth, but I’m trying to get back up to where we were. We’re still improving the site and adding features. It’s still a valuable service. That’s kind of where it stands at the moment.

How did you come up with your ideas for your apps?

A lot of it is solving a problem that I have personally. SocialToo started because I was on Twitter and I wanted to follow back all of the people that followed me to show appreciation for what they had done. I started doing it and I realized that it was getting to be too big of a burden for me to manage, to manually do this for everyone. I figured that I could automate this process rather than doing it manually, so I built a script that allows you to auto-follow people who follow you. Chris Pirillo was the first one who mentioned that he had an interest in an app that would be able to auto-follow people that followed him. I was following him on Twitter, and his blog, and I wrote him a blog post saying, “Hey, I’ve got this tool. Come use it.” So I open sourced it and released the code. Chris saw that and asked me if he could use it.

Shortly after that, Guy Kawasaki had a similar need and I made the same offer to him. I realized that he was a little less technical than Chris and that we needed to build a user interface around this to make it easier. It was at that point that SocialToo was born. It started out as a site to build tools that compliment your social networking use. Now it’s moving more towards a social reputation management platform for companies.

The social media space is changing very rapidly. How do you stay ahead of the curve?

A lot of it is just doing what makes sense. Finding the right people to pay attention to and follow plays a lot into it. Follow the early adopters like Robert Scoble and Louis Gray, as well as the blogs like Tech Crunch and Mashable, and see what they’re talking about. If there is a lot of the same buzz about a particular topic then that’s generally a good product to at least get on your radar and understand what it is.

But then there is the other side of it. Early adopters are often wrong. You have to take information from those sources and determine how it’s actually going to help you. You have to ask, “How is that going to help a brand? How is that going to help a business?” And not just by increasing numbers, but how is it going to actually help gain customers and build value? How is it going to help improve your reputation? And once you can answer those questions with these popular technologies, then you know you’ve got something that is going to stick.

I also use Twitter and Twitter lists. The key to know what to follow is you have to find influential people and figure out where they like to hang out. Some of them like to hang out on Twitter. Lately, Robert Scoble likes to hang out on Quora. I actually met Scoble because he used to FriendFeed. He moves around and I just followed him on FriendFeed and we became good friends as a result of that. Some people prefer to communicate on their blogs. Find out where they participate and then start getting to know them and following them in those areas. That’s where you’ll get the really good information. Get a Google Reader account and start subscribing to your favorite blogs. I like to make it a point to subscribe to Utah blogs whenever I find a good tech blog from Utah that makes sense. That way, I’m helping to promote Utah when I can, too.

Then, start building friends on Google Reader and rely on their shares. Build a good strategy around managing that so that it’s not taking up too much your time. I get most of my information from Google Reader. With my Google Reader I skim most of my articles. I have numerous Twitter lists that I skim through. Once you’ve developed both a good group of people that you’re following on Google Reader and a list of blogs that you’re subscribed to, that’s often sufficient enough to get you the information you need to stay current.

How do you effectively use social media like Twitter and Facebook to improve your business and ultimately the bottom line?

Effective depends on your definition of the term. There are different strategies. You might want to just increase your audience. That’s one strategy. Improving your reputation is another strategy. Increasing revenue is another strategy. Improving communication is another strategy. Building community is another strategy. So, all these things are different pieces to the way that social media can help. As far as building numbers, that’s easy. Building numbers is something anyone can do.  You follow someone on Twitter and chances are that they are going to follow you back. A lot of people on Facebook, if you send them a friend request, are going to accept that friend request even if they don’t know you. That’s just a fact whether it makes sense or not. It’s easy to build numbers.

What is hard is to build relationships with those people. All of the other pieces like the reputation, the community building, the revenue increasing, will improve if you can focus on relationships. Relationships are the key. You don’t have to just do it on Twitter. In fact, Facebook is almost more effective now. If I were to start over again, I would probably start on Facebook, with a Facebook page in conjunction with my personal account.

You need to focus on genuine relationships with people, like I did with Guy and Chris. I noticed that they had a need and I offered to help. And I just genuinely wanted to help. I wasn’t doing it to try and gain their interest in me or anything like that. In fact, I didn’t even know very much of who they were at the time that I approached them. Business naturally comes from that and ideas flow from that as well. The same goes with any use of social media. If you’re going to benefit your business you have to focus on relationships and not numbers. When you’re focusing on relationships, the numbers will naturally happen. And even if you don’t have the big numbers, the conversion rate that you’re trying to get from that use will happen. Numbers don’t mean much. It’s what you’re getting from those numbers that matter.

When I consult with people, I don’t just look at how we can build a Facebook page or how we can add a Twitter or YouTube account. I start with their own technology. I ask them, “How can we use your own technology and integrate it with social media to build better relationships? How can we foster relationships within this environment?” That may or may not involve Facebook. Then, I look outside of their technology and ask, “How can we use external sites and technologies to build relationships? If we look at Facebook and Twitter and we can only devote time to one of them, which one are we going to choose? Which one is going to give us the best bang for our buck?” And that might be a different answer depending on what you’re doing. Often it’s Facebook, but the key again is to ask how you can build relationships with these people and which network is going to help you build relationships the best.

You have to figure out if your audience is even on Twitter or on Facebook. You’ll see a lot of news organizations on Twitter because much of their audience is on Twitter. You’ve got to figure out where your audience is. You have to figure out ways that you can connect to your audience and ways that they can connect to you and build relationships.

So clarify a little bit more what you mean by “relationships”. What does it mean to build relationships?

Let’s start with a website for instance. Traditional websites are organized by content. They’re organized by categories and by a directory type of structure where you have one main page and then you have topics that have been pre-chosen by the organization as to what goes there. Well, rather than that, why not take the user’s Facebook friends or Twitter friends and organize the content that way? What are their friends sharing? What are their friends interested in? That presents a much more fascinating architecture than the traditional “this is what we want you to read” architecture. It builds relationships as users use it because these people are seeing what their friends are doing and then talking with their friends about what they just read on your site. And now you’ve put your site into their conversations and into their communication. Now you’re a part of their culture. That’s one piece of the relationships side.

When you deal with Facebook and Twitter and third party sites you’re kind of doing the same thing. With a Facebook page you’re putting your message out there, but you’re letting people talk about it and you’re letting them like it and share it with their friends. Again, your message is getting injected into their conversations and it becomes a part of their culture as a result. Once you’re a part of their culture they will naturally want to purchase your products. They will naturally want to share and your reputation will naturally grow because your community will grow and your community will stand up for you. As a result, people will be more aware of you.

You should focus on each individual user and ask yourself, “How can I use relationships and foster relationships to help improve this particular thing that we’re trying to fix?” And you’ll find that the really good social strategists will focus on this and not just on the Facebook page or the Twitter account. That’s the key.

So talk specifically for a minute about entrepreneurs. What is some advice that you would give entrepreneurs about how to implement what you’ve just talked about?

It’s easier now for entrepreneurs. When I started my business I was a programmer type. I didn’t have a whole lot of marketing knowledge. I didn’t really know how to promote my site and get visibility for it. Well, once Facebook released their platform and I could start integrating Facebook API into what I was doing, suddenly I had a platform for promoting what I was doing and it would naturally sell itself without me having to buy an advertisement or hire a PR agency. It would naturally share itself amongst my peers and their peers and it would spread that way. So these platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube allow you to interject into these relationships. You can really use them to your advantage.

For technology entrepreneurs, you can now integrate Facebook into your product to enable your product to naturally share itself. And it’s really simple. Your programmers shouldn’t need too much additional knowledge to be able to integrate this. At a minimum you go to http://developers.facebook.com/docs/plugins/ and there is a whole list of what they call “social plug ins” where you can copy and paste code into your website and immediately see the most liked items on your website. So, there are some very simple ways now that you can start integrating these tools into your own technology to have it naturally share itself. It’s a lot easier than it used to be to spread word about your product.

And at the same time, the advent of blogs and the advent of social networking enable you to go out and build relationships and get in touch with these people in ways that you weren’t able to before. You can now talk to Guy Kawasaki, Robert Scoble, Mike Arrington and others and you can do so openly and easily in ways that you weren’t able to before. So go out and build relationships using the social networks and through blogs and stuff like that. You can be building relationships with these influencers and the bloggers to get word out about your product.

So, to get into it a little bit more, how do you make sure that what you post online is seen by others so that you can start building these relationships? It’s easy to just post something online. How can you make sure it’s seen?

Follow smart people. Seriously, as you start to follow others, they will pay attention. I recommend having a blog. On your blog, link to these people and they will pay attention. They will start to pay attention and a lot of them will follow you back. As you start to post more information and information that is interesting to them, they will start to pay attention to you. But start by following them. Get to know them first. They’re not going to get to know you until you spend some time getting to know them. Once you spend some time getting to know them, you will have done your investment and they will naturally start to build relationships with you. You will start to know how you can get in better contact with them. You’ll start to know what their likes and dislikes are. You’ll start to learn how to pitch ideas to them because you will know how they like to hear things. They’ll recognize you when you try to contact them. The more you get to know these people and try to build real relationships with them, the more they will start to pay attention. And that’s the secret. That’s all that I’ve done.

I was looking over your LinkedIn profile and I saw you had some slides posted about a concept that you call “Fishers to Farmers”. Tell me a little bit about that.

There’s a concept in social media called fishing where the fish are. It’s actually a marketing term. The idea is that you go out to where your audience is naturally and you inject your message there so that your audience naturally shares it and brings it to their friends. An example of this would be a Facebook app, or allowing users to share information on their Facebook, or even email their friends about your product. An even more traditional model would be giving them a t-shirt to wear amongst their friends or something like that. That’s all fishing where the fish are and it’s an effective model for getting your brand out there. It’s a model that isn’t going away.

But where things are evolving towards now, is what I call farming or going from “Fishers to Farmers”. Instead of going out to where your audience is, you are building farms for them to come back to your site and to your turf and to be able to have those same experiences that they have with their friends in an environment that they’re familiar with. It’s like when I was talking about organizing the content by relationships instead of by categories. That would be an example of building a farm and bringing them back to your site. You should build experiences on your own site rather than having to put out your message where they are. I recommend a combination of both fishing and farming, but that is what I call farming.

You’re going to start to see more and more sites do this. Right now, if you go to huffingonpost.com and you click on either the Twitter link or the Facebook login link, once you associate either account it will automatically organize the content based on who you’re friends with. Digg does this too. Instead of having to go to Facebook to try to sift out Digg information, I can now go to Digg.com and it’s all sorted by my Facebook friends which I’ve already established on Facebook. So that’s the idea. Does that make sense?

Yes. And this is where you see a lot of websites going in the future?

I think it’s going to move more and more towards that, yes. Social media will be ubiquitive. It will follow every experience and permeate every experience that you participate in. You won’t have to go just to Facebook to get what you want. You’ll go from site to site to see it. I call this concept “the web with no login button”. It’s where, in the future, the web will follow you. And not just the social experiences, but the web in general will follow you from site to site and use your browser to identify who you are and who your friends are. And your browser will automatically adapt those sites for your experience. You’ll never have to login or anything because your browser will already know who you are. And you’ll immediately get a completely contextual, very relevant experience targeted just to you.

What do you like about having your business here in Utah and why would you recommend for other people to start tech businesses here, as opposed to places like Silicon Valley and Boston?

So the question is, do you go to Silicon Valley where you’ve got the networking opportunities and the rich talent, or do you stay in Utah? It’s a tough question, because I’ve been tempted a few times myself. The answer for Utah is that Utah is cheap. It’s a good family environment and it’s a good place to operate a business at a low cost. There is a much greater potential for high profit. And now you can do almost everything you need to remotely. If you know how to use the social networks, you don’t have to go out to Silicon Valley and meet those people in person. You can do it virtually now. It’s becoming more and more possible for people to be able to operate a business in Utah and have that Silicon Valley environment and never have to actually meet that environment.

I do recommend that if you start a business in Utah, a tech business, that you go out to Silicon Valley every so often and meet some of the people out there and introduce your business there. There’s a good chance you probably won’t get in front of Robert Scoble unless you actually go out to Silicon Valley. And if you want to get an interview with any of those guys in person you’re going to have to go out there eventually. Unless you’re an investor, you can pretty much get away with building a business in Utah now and networking with the people in Silicon Valley. I think it’s completely possible, I used to not think that, but I think it’s more and more possible today than it ever was.

Utah just has so many opportunities. We have one of the highest employment rates in the country at the moment. Twitter is here now, Omniture is here, Oracle is here, EBay is here, and a whole host of others. It’s becoming a hot bed, especially in the hosting area. It’s becoming a really strong hot bed for tech and I don’t think you’re going to have much of a problem finding a job here. In fact, you’re going to find a pretty good job with good experience and with a big name company if you need to. Or, you can start up a new company and I don’t think you’ll have a problem finding the investment you need either. There are plenty of investors here.

There are two problems here in Utah that I can see and that we can improve on. One problem is that we have plenty of entrepreneurs, but entrepreneurs aren’t holding it through. We have no Google or Microsoft or Facebook, where the entrepreneur starts a company and holds it through and doesn’t sell out in the end. Silicon Valley has a great advantage in that respect. They also think more in terms of causes, and not just businesses there. I’d love to see Utah do this more. Be crazy. Think of what is going to change the world and not just what is going to make money. Build those ideas even if you can’t figure out a way to make money at first. Those are the good ideas to get investment for and move forward with. Those are the ideas that often become a Google, or a Microsoft, or a Twitter, or a Facebook.

So there is that side of it. The other side of it is promotion. We don’t have a lot of tech bloggers in Utah. We have a few, but not a whole lot that have an audience outside of Utah. It’s a very tight, niche audience. People outside of Utah aren’t fully listening to us. We need more tech bloggers that are targeting audiences outside of Utah and are trying to build audiences on a more general basis to highlight the companies within Utah. Once we have that then we’ll be able to get people paying attention to Utah.